This paper sets out to discuss “getting people there”, where we are currently and hopefully open up the debate to embrace new ways of looking at reducing the issues of anxiety driven by the pace of life and also at increasing a sense of public confidence.
Since time immemorial human beings have made gestures in attempts to communicate either by hand or through body language. Not all have been fully understood. Signage has become a particular problem. The places people walk, meet, play, drive and generally go about their business have become an ‘instruction park’.
In less frenetic times, places announced themselves, you knew when you had arrived and simply asked for directions.
Today the development of the urban environment at all levels is still exercising politicians and professionals alike, from Alsop planning a revitalised Barnsley to Rogers looking at London’s spaces, juggling and walking the fine lines between quality of life, communication and the needs of business.
Nowadays from the retail centre to the transport hub and the business park, people need particular help to know where they are and where they’re supposed to go.
These often conflicting requirements have now reached the status of a science… but is it joined-up science?
The Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea are actively addressing the current situation. They, following experiments in Holland, are taking away signage, not adding it.
The situation has grown to such an ‘explosion of ironmongery’ partly because agencies appear not to have an agreed philosophical approach to urban issues from which those providing the distinctive parts can draw guidance, over and above spatial and corporate rules.
We think it is time that a full and proper debate on the constituent elements that go into making the urban scene should be engaged in jointly by all those who contribute to it via their separate disciplines. Maybe then wayfinding will not be an ‘add on’ along with landscaping, lighting and art.
What if we dared to ask a land artist or filmmaker or installation artist to lead the debate? Maybe some of their concepts of perimeters, barriers, focal points the lines made by walking or using familiar and simple means e.g. bicycles, could promote a fuller discussion on the form visual elements in the landscape might take?
These issues were raised in an Arts Council sponsored exhibition in 1973, ‘How to Play the Environment Game’, where Theo Crosby was concerned that planning and building should be developing a social utopia as well as a physical one
The following images are set to raise the question, the answers will be the result of the analysis of the specific, the history, location, the purpose of any project and the openness brought to the discussion. The ‘Nonsite’ cannot be delivered where the discussion environment does not set the limits, but challenges the limits of those who participate.
If the simplification in architecture is not to render the cityscape into universal uniformity, there is no question that questions need to be asked. There is a need to redeliver a sense of place. Whether that is the ‘percent for art’ programme is questionable. What is needed however is a proper understanding of what makes environments work and how people respond to them.
Again from Crosby, a large part of the answer might just be “finding a viable reason and context for working in a way that allows instincts, beliefs and urges irrefutably dictate”.
And adding art indiscriminately into an already ‘adequately’ cluttered environment is to add to the chaos. Technology and fashions change.
Maybe the discussion is the suggestion that there is a future with more emphasis on temporary, flexible and expendable manifestations. This is not to deny that permanence provides a sense of continuity and security.
What we are postulating is that consideration of all the interventions... lighting, seating, water, landscaping… and particularly wayfinding… as a comprehensive whole at the point of design, delivering the sense of something special is a distinct possibility.
Sectorlight is a brand consultancy involved in providing marketing communications, design and wayfinding services internationally, particularly in relation to urban regeneration and major mixed-use property development projects. We have the staff base, creative intellect and hands-on experience to make a positive mark on, and contribution to, your special project.